30 days FREE from Class 9 to DropperRegister free

The binding energy of a H-atom, considering an electron moving around a fixed nucleus (Bohr model), is given by (taking the electron's charge and mass as e and m respectively, with other symbols having their usual meaning): E_n = -(me⁴)/(8n²ε₀²h²). If one decides to work in a frame of reference where the electron is at rest, the corresponding expression obtained by transferring mass from the electron to the proton (to retain the same expression) would not be correct, because

PhysicsAtoms · Reference Frame in the Bohr Model
  • A. n would no longer be integral.
  • B. Bohr-quantisation applies only to the electron.
  • C. the frame in which the electron is taken to be at rest is not an inertial frame.
  • D. the motion of the proton would not be in circular orbits, even approximately.
Show answer & explanation

Answer: (C) the frame in which the electron is taken to be at rest is not an inertial frame.

Explanation

The Bohr model's quantisation rules are derived assuming motion relative to an inertial frame. A frame in which the orbiting electron is instantaneously at rest is a non-inertial (accelerating) frame, so the same quantisation condition and resulting energy expression cannot simply be transferred to it by swapping the electron and proton mass.

Practise every Atoms question with a timer

Chapter tests, full NEET mocks, your score and weak topics — 70,000+ questions on YNeet.

Start free for 30 days

No payment, no card. Sign up in 30 seconds.

For Class 11, 12 and droppers, see what the YNeet NEET online course includes.

More Atoms questions

All free Atoms PYQs →