The electron gain enthalpy of fluorine is less negative than that of chlorine, even though fluorine is more electronegative. Which combination of reasons best explains this?
- A. Fluorine has a higher nuclear charge and larger atomic size than chlorine
- B. Fluorine has a smaller atomic size leading to greater electron-electron repulsion in the compact 2p subshell, and chlorine has a larger, more diffuse 3p orbital that accommodates the incoming electron better
- C. Fluorine has a lower nuclear charge and its 2p orbitals are less shielded than chlorine's 3p orbitals
- D. Chlorine has stronger nuclear attraction due to its higher atomic number, making its electron gain enthalpy more negative
Show answer & explanation
Answer: (B) Fluorine has a smaller atomic size leading to greater electron-electron repulsion in the compact 2p subshell, and chlorine has a larger, more diffuse 3p orbital that accommodates the incoming electron better
Explanation
Despite fluorine being the most electronegative element, its electron gain enthalpy (−328 kJ/mol) is less negative than chlorine's (−349 kJ/mol). This anomaly occurs because fluorine has a very small atomic size (atomic radius ~64 pm). When an extra electron is added to fluorine's already compact 2p subshell, there is significant inter-electronic repulsion among the electrons in the small 2p orbitals. Chlorine has larger 3p orbitals that are more diffuse and spatially extended, so they can accommodate the incoming electron with much less repulsion, resulting in a more negative electron gain enthalpy for Cl than for F. Electronegativity is a different concept (related to bond polarity) and doesn't directly contradict this trend.
Practise every Classification of Elements and Periodicity in Properties question with a timer
Chapter tests, full NEET mocks, your score and weak topics — 70,000+ questions on YNeet.
Start free for 30 daysNo payment, no card. Sign up in 30 seconds.
For Class 11, 12 and droppers, see what the YNeet NEET online course includes.
More Classification of Elements and Periodicity in Properties questions
- Among the following options, the correct trend in the electron gain enthalpy (magnitude, most exothermic… (NEET 2026)
- The correct order of increasing metallic character of Na, Be, P, Mg and Si is: (NEET 2026)
- Although +3 oxidation state is the most common for lanthanoids, cerium still shows +4 oxidation state because: (NEET 2026)
- Identify the incorrect statement from the following: (1) Oxygen exhibits only -2 oxidation state. (2) The… (NEET 2026)
- Identify the incorrect statement from the following: (1) The largest and the smallest species among Mg… (NEET 2026)
- Which of the following statements are true? A. Unlike Ga that has a very high melting point, Cs, has a very… (NEET 2025)
- Which among the following electronic configurations belong to main group elements? A. Ne 3s¹, B. Ar 3d³4s²… (NEET 2025)
- The element expected to form the largest ion to achieve the nearest noble gas configuration is: (NEET 2023)